Additions and conversions
Can my house take a second story?
Short answer
Possibly, and a structural engineer answers it, not a contractor and certainly not a salesman. The three questions are whether the foundation and footings can carry the load, whether the existing walls can, and whether lot coverage and height limits allow it.
Get the engineering report first
It is the cheapest step in the project and the only one that can end the conversation before you spend real money. A block first floor is often in reasonable shape for load in Florida, but the tie-downs and the connection detailing are what the engineer is actually working out, and those are not cheap to build.
What the budget has to include
- Engineering, and a survey if you do not have a current one.
- Temporary roof removal and weather protection, which in this climate is not a formality.
- A new staircase, which eats floor area downstairs that you will not get back.
- A second HVAC zone or a second system.
- Very likely an electrical panel upgrade.
The staircase is the one people forget. It takes space from the floor that currently works, and on a small footprint it can undo the reason you wanted more room.
The planning constraints
Height limits and lot coverage are set by your zoning district, and an HOA can add its own. Check both with the parcel ID before you commission drawings, the same way you would for an accessory dwelling unit.
The order that saves money
- Zoning and HOA check.
- Structural engineer report on the existing house.
- Concept drawings, only once the first two say yes.
- Budget with allowances, then permit drawings.
If the report says no, the alternatives are out rather than up: an addition against moving, or reworking the existing layout, which starts with is this wall load-bearing.
The alternative the engineer may suggest
On some houses it is cheaper to remove the existing roof structure and build a new floor than to reinforce what is there, and on others the answer is to go out rather than up. An engineer who is asked for options rather than a yes or no will usually give you both.
Either way the sequence is the same: engineering first, then planning, then design, then price. Reversing that order is how people spend money on drawings for something that was never going to be permitted.
What it does to the rest of the house
A second storey is rarely only a second storey. The staircase changes the ground floor, the air conditioning usually needs a second zone, and the electrical service often has to grow, so parts of the existing house get rebuilt whether or not that was the plan.
Budget for finishing the ground floor back to a whole house, not just for the new rooms above it. That line is what people leave out of the comparison against moving.
Krisi Kakarova, World Properties Group
A licensed Florida Realtor (SL3327932) and a Certified Residential Building Contractor (CRC1335654), working in Seminole, Orange and Volusia County. Holding both is why these answers price the transaction and the construction together — more about how I work.
Last reviewed
Want this answered for your house?
Send the address or the plan. You will get the same answer as above, with the part that depends on your roof, your slab and your street filled in.
Ask about your house